About Us

Cuddy Insurance delivers over 90 years of insurance expertise.

Contact one of our seasoned insurance consultants and they will be in touch with you shortly.

 Serving the insurance needs of North Brookfield, Massachusetts since 1923!

Betsy Cuddy

Betsy, President of Cuddy Insurance, has been with the company since 1986. She has over 30 years’ experience in both personal and commercial insurance. She completed her CIC (Certified Insurance Counselor) training and received designation in 2014. Betsy is the third generation owner of Cuddy Insurance Agency, which remains the only family owned and operated agency in town.

Betsy is a trustee of the North Brookfield Savings Bank and volunteers at many other organizations with the community.

Betsy earned her Bachelor’s degree from Colorado State University in Ft. Collins, Co. and currently resides in Petersham, MA with her husband.

Betsy Cuddy
Heidi Hunderup

Heidi Hunderup

Heidi has been a Customer Service Representative at Cuddy Insurance Agency for 20 years. She has over 35 years of experience in personal lines focusing primarily on Massachusetts auto and homeowners insurance.

Heidi remains busy outside of work and is passionately involved with many local town and church activities.

Tony Martinelli

Tony joined the agency in January of 2018. Prior to joining Cuddy Insurance, he worked for MAPFRE Insurance Company for 4 years. He is the 4th generation to work at Cuddy Insurance Agency and is Betsy’s youngest son.

Tony is a 2014 graduate of Southern New Hampshire University where he majored in business.

Tony resides in Worcester, Ma with his wife Brittany.

Tony Martinelli
Kayla Hunderup

Kayla Hunderup

Kayla is our newest employee at Cuddy Insurance Agency, Inc., and the daughter of Heidi Hunderup. Kayla got engaged in July 2020 and has been with her soon to be husband for ten years. She is new to the insurance industry and loves to learn something new every day.

Contact Kayla today for help with any of your insurance needs by calling 508-867-6850.


See What You Can Save!

Cuddy Insurance Agency

Family owned and operated since 1923.

220 N Main St,

North Brookfield, MA 01535

Phone: 508-867-6850
Fax: 508-867-0129


Mon - Thurs: 8AM to 4:30PM

Friday: 8AM to 4PM

We are licensed in the state of Massachusetts.